Most claims against business owners and senior managers don’t come from intentionally bad behaviour.
They come from doing your best in a complex environment: employing people, making judgment calls, navigating regulation, and trying to keep a business moving forward.
And yet, when something goes wrong, the consequences can land squarely on the shoulders of the people in charge.
For many SME owners, that’s a reality they don’t fully appreciate until they’re exposed to it.
What is Management Liability insurance?
Management Liability insurance is designed to protect directors, senior managers and the company against claims arising from the way a business is run.
It responds to specified claims of wrongdoing and is particularly relevant for SMEs.
In most cases, Management Liability policies are made up of several key sections, including:
- Directors’ & Officers’ Liability
- Company reimbursement
- Employment Practices Liability
- Occupational Health & Safety defence costs
- Statutory Liability
- Crime
- Tax Audit
Together, these sections provide protection for both the individuals behind the business and, in some circumstances, the business entity itself.
Why SMEs are particularly exposed
A common misconception is that Management Liability is only relevant for large corporations.
In reality, SMEs can be more exposed, because:
- Owners and managers wear multiple hats
- Employment and HR decisions are often made without specialist advice
- Compliance obligations continue to increase
- There is less margin for error when something goes wrong
Importantly, claims don’t require intentional wrongdoing. They often arise from:
- Employment disputes such as unfair dismissal, discrimination or bullying
- Alleged breaches of workplace health and safety obligations
- Claims that directors failed to meet their duties
- Investigations by regulators such as WorkSafe or the ATO
Even where a business owner believes they’ve acted reasonably, allegations alone can trigger costly legal processes.
Personal exposure is often overlooked
Another common assumption is that claims are made against the company only.
In practice, directors and managers can be named personally, meaning their own assets and finances can be at risk if they are not adequately protected.
This is particularly relevant for family-owned businesses and SMEs, where the lines between the business and the individuals running it are closely connected.
Management Liability insurance exists to respond when decisions made in a professional capacity are later questioned, often with the benefit of hindsight.
The hidden cost: defence and legal expenses
One of the most significant risks for SMEs isn’t always the outcome of a claim; it’s the cost of defending it.
Legal representation, responding to regulators, preparing documentation and managing proceedings can quickly become expensive and time-consuming, even if no breach is ultimately found.
For business owners, this often coincides with the ongoing pressure of running the business itself, adding stress at an already challenging time.
Management Liability insurance can respond to defence costs for covered claims, helping to ensure that the financial burden of defending the business doesn’t become the issue that ultimately causes harm.
Why other insurance policies don’t fill the gap
Many SMEs assume they are already covered because they hold:
- Business insurance
- Public liability
- Professional indemnity
However, these policies are not designed to respond to claims about how a business is managed, or allegations relating to governance, employment practices or statutory obligations.
Management Liability insurance is specifically designed to fill this gap: protecting decision-makers when their actions, or alleged failures to act, come under scrutiny.
A necessary consideration for modern SMEs
Running a business today involves navigating increasingly complex legal and regulatory obligations, often with limited resources and competing priorities.
Management Liability insurance isn’t about expecting something to go wrong – it’s about recognising that even well-run businesses can face allegations, and ensuring the business, and the people behind the business, are protected if that happens.
This article provides information rather than financial product or other advice. The content of this article, including any information contained in it, has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. You should consider the appropriateness of the information, taking these matters into account, before you act on any information. In particular, you should review the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) for any product that the information relates to before acquiring the product.
Information is current as at the date the article is written as specified within it but is subject to change. Breakwater Insurance Brokers make no representation as to the accuracy or completeness of the information. All information is subject to copyright and may not be reproduced without the prior written consent of Breakwater Insurance Brokers.
